— — — —— — —
×
— —— —
— — — —— — —
×
— —— —
— — — —— — —
×
— —— —
← darkroom
What is wrong with my list?
Rip my list to shreds. Tell me everything you find wrong, or right. I want to hear opinions that differ from my own. I may consider rewatching a show if so many disagree to try and grasp your point of view. I may also look at your list and rip yours too, such is life.
Your list isn't bad at all. In fact I agree with you on most shows we've both seen. There is one thing wrong with it though.... Monster is still in your planning! You need to watch it immediately!
Edit: I hated Angel Beats and you loved it so there's that.
I am currently reading Vagabond so everything is on hold right now. I will watch and read monster. I loved the concept of Angel Beats and how it was meant for young people to fulfill the time they missed in the real world. I guess I like it much more than others, but maybe it is because I am a teen.
10 manga. 1 completed.
I am the sad right now.
I've not watched thiis many anime yet myself, so not the best judge here :p your list is pretty good, but i'd also disagree with Angel Beats... The very concept is really interesting indeed, but i found it was executed poorly. Also i personally didn't really enjoy Fate/Zero, the animation was tremendous and the story and characters had huge potential, but again i felt that it didn't deliver in the end. Since the Fate universe is really vast, i felt like some things were simply left unexplained and when i googled them, i realized that they get answered in other parts of the Fate franchise, which makes it weak standing alone as it's own story. Also i was expecting more action tbh. But these are personal opinions ofc, i get why other people would like those things, i guess :p
I don't mean any harm, but I would like to point out that Fate/Zero was never intended to be started with. That might be part of your confusion. I don't mean any harm once again.
i know i know, i had researched a looot about the franchise before starting since i knew it was a bit complicated... i didn't want to watch the studio DEEN versions 'cause i saw a lot of people saying they're kinda meh and that ufotable's are better... Then wondering with which one of ufotable to start, i saw many people suggesting chronological both release and event order, saying to either start with Fate/Zero or even watch it on it's own without UBW... Idk, maybe bad advice after all :p thanks for being polite though, some people go berserk when they see sth they disagree with hahah
It's YOUR list, nothing wrong about it. If you want my point of view, it is quite good and very similar to mine, I just don't agree with your score of Cowboy Bebop, but my opinions doesn't matter.
HxH at 9.7 instead of 10 and Code Geass is not 10/10 worth imo (too many filler episodes and coincidences) and Death Note is a little too high
but your list overall is really decentI personally did not like Genthru and most of Greed Island so that is why it is not a 10, but 9.7 is still a masterpiece. I guess I enjoy the mystery and thriller genre a lot, so Death Note and Code Geass more than most. I liked the filler episodes and the coincidences were semi planned by Lelouch.
I like thriller and mystery genre a lot too (10/10 for the promised neverland) and I REALLY enjoyed Death Note for 20-few episodes but those few last episodes were pretty underwhelimng. That's why I gave DN 8 instead of 9.
I don't like Genthru too but he's still decent villain maybe even better than a lot of other shounen villains that last only 1 arc.
imo greed island is perfect bridge between dark yorknew arc and even darker chimera ant arc. After colorful nice GI arc show immediately throw you into the darkest arc of the series and that "shock-effect" (idk how to cal it) works perfectly. And GI had a lot of sick moments itself too (hisoka, dodge ball, final fight vs bombers, phantom troup and one of the best "training moments" overall imo)
Overall decent but demon slayer was terrible, fullmetal alchemist brotherhood was a bit better than an 8.3, and then code geass. Code geass is great and all but season 1 is not the best anime on your list and is defeninetly not better than season 2. But why is hunter not a 10. Hunter is the best anime ever in my opinion and should be better than code geass. Overall not 2 shabby doe.
I did not like the Chinese Federation in season 2, so that is why I liked Code Geass season 1 more than season 2. I liked almost all the character and the symbolism of Zero is an ideal not a person. Season 1 was the most thrilling and enjoyable show I personally watched. I like that genre the most, which is why I enjoyed the show more than most. Demon Slayer was okay, but Zenitsu is why its a 7 not a 5. I did not think FMAB was incredible, but it was very good. The Chinese girl I hated and did not especially like Father and some of the Homunculi. Roy is a don and I wish he was the protagonist of a sequel as Ferhur.
First I want to start by saying that it's your list and you are entilted to your opinion, so no salt pls haha, but the thing I disagree with the most is having anohana and boku no hero season 3 so low. I know MHA is overrated as hell, I admit it myself even though I love the show, but seriously? asterisk war over these two? Idk but I really thought asterisk was just bad from every single angle, characters, settings, animation (except opening tho, both openings are 10/10.)
BTW if you happened to enjoy asterisk war atleast a bit, I recommend Rakudai kishi, which is very similar but a lot better IMO.
