lockedAnime

Your Name or A Silent Voice

802

I'm looking to start a war with this thread. Its a disgrace that Your name is rated higher than A Silent Voice
A Silent Voice >>>>>> Your Name

Ihavenoidea12222 5y
A silent voice >>> Your name
Byrott 5y
Definitely A Silent Voice
AkiZ 5y
Imma have to go silent voice
h8yana 5y
a silent voice duh
leclerc 5y
Your Name = A Silent Voice
neither is better
- Byrott 5y
  Cap
Faesunya 5y
Next up on today's episode of lukewarm takes: this thread.
- Removed 5y
  Lukewarm? This is a Spitwarm take.
  Faesunya 5y
  Fair enough
Iero 5y
I've always said that Makoto Shinkai's films are some of the most overrated anime of all times. They are holes with the plot on the corner, stupid characters, a fake rappresentation of Japan and treats their thems in childish ways. A Silent Voice is not on the best anime films of all times, despite the fact that I love it, but there is no competition
cheeseplush 5y
the meteor in your name is a better character than every single character in a silent voice
- Removed 5y
  Leave.
kappamoshi 5y
In the spirit of keeping the war alive (or maybe I'm being honest)...

Kimi no Na wa >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Koe no Katachi
user327563 5y
Definitely A Silent Voice
0649framboise 5y
for me i prefer A Silent Voice
Bokunomuichiro 5y
A Silent Voice is better
Leofc037 5y
a silent voice is def better than your name but i still prefer your name tho, different ppl have different tastes, if not then everyone should think fmab is the best anime ever
davidman001 5y
neither of them are better
xhael 5y
your name .. i didn't rlly like a silent voice tbh
lilwho 5y
silent voice is the best anime movie ive ever seen hands down
Quannix 5y
i think silent voice is a lot better but it's not that big of a deal that your name is rated higher. i mean i don't agree with the placement of any of the top 10 anime except for steins gate
JLom 5y
Easily A SIlent Voice. Your Name's good but it just doesn't have the same level of empathy and connection as Silent Voice- Silent Voice really nails the human interactions and themes of suicide, Your Name is more lighthearted romance imo
daijoubu 5y
a silent voice>>>>> your name could never compare
SophiaWithAph 5y
I meaaaaannnn Your name is has a really amazing concept but A Silent Voice is pretty relatable. I like both, cant decide
JkunAL 5y
Frankly, I don't prefer either of them. If someone forced me to decide, I'd say Your Name.
- Removed 5y
  I'm forcing you to decide A Silent Voice
Camba 5y
Your name story is a creative idea, but it was such a waste of time that only good thing I can point out is animation quality. Silent voice is a story, not a what the hell is going on in this movie like Your name is, if you catch my drift.
- aquamatic 5y
  Honestly same. Your Name had a creative idea, but towards the end it fell apart. When I finished the movie my first thought was 'what just happened?' I liked A silent voice a lot more because it felt relatable and the story was better executed than Your Name.
reed 5y
my name is reed and i dont know what a silent voice means
IdiotKun 5y
Haven't seen Your Name, but A Silent Voice got me wishing Shouko was real.
Don't reply I'm down horrendous rn
19Sith 5y
Silent voice literally hit differently than your name ever did
- Rahimdas 5y
  Sorry for hitting you with my name
MrHatz4Patz 5y
I mean, that's like the common opinion already as far as I know, so I don't really see how this is starting much of a war.
Broheros 5y
a silent voice was an amazing movie. but it leaves my favorite parts of the manga out. i really enjoyed your name too, but the second half was very confusing. both have really good soundtracks and visuals.
SpiceAndWife 5y
A Silent Voice
ChirekachiMizu 5y
I prefer both actually.
- Your Name is better in terms of visuals
- A Silent Voice is better in terms of story
Both have likeable characters. So it's a perfect balance
Excalibur1 5y
Your Name was the better romance story for me, but as a feels movie Silent Voice was really good. Both have their own appeal.

more replies on anilist →