Forum Games

What's the rating from the above user's anime list that surprised you the most?

SmashBlack · 4y

27237

Title

3115

Rd0310 1y
Fair enough lmao, can relate to the last bit too
Urobot 1y
Ahaha, yep, and I'm sticking by that 10! I went in with low expectations tbh, and ended up just loving everything about it. It's an absurd premise that I think they pull off pretty well, I like all the characters, and the op and ed are some of my favorite anime songs of all time.

I went back and forth between giving it a 9 or 10 for a while until I settled on 10
SpongeInf 4y
@middentyu02
The rating for 86 six is bit too much
- Narutonic 3y
  Too high? (jk)
  but I actually agree with 6
- Illamma 4y
  bruh
- ananieah 3y
  @Spongelnf rating for erased too low?
Millufer 3y
My main problem with this show is that the other characters aren't as explored as the main 2. Don't get me wrong tho, I still enjoyed the ride.

Also you kinda hit the mark with me being allergic to shoujo and josei lol, I used to watch shoujo anime back in the days but not anymore
middentyu02 4y
@SmashBlack
PSYCHO.PASS 5,9/10

The concept and the characters are top tier ( especially the "villain" Makishima Shogo ).
I know the second half is less interesting and there are some weird plot
The connection between Tsunemori and the Sibyl system

But I think this anime deserve more

The death of Makishima alone deserve a 10/10 rating
Urobot 1y
Ahaha, yep, and I'm sticking by that 10! I went in with low expectations tbh, and ended up just loving everything about it. It's an absurd premise that I think they pull off pretty well, I like all the characters, and the op and ed are some of my favorite anime songs of all time.

I went back and forth between giving it a 9 or 10 for a while until I settled on 10
Removed 4y
@MONGKIDxOP
Psycho-pass a 4...?
- SpongeInf 4y
  I am not into psychology or mystery ones not that much but I love monster,death note etc
randomgayname 4y
@Psyc0ticK1ll3r

Uh Violet Evergarden should be a 0.
Tho the ratings are not rly suprising.

Also did you take your name straight out of 2006?
- Removed 4y
  nah, more like ~2011 I'd say. I was one edgy 11 year old, I ain't gonna lie... too lazy to come up with a better one.
  
  & damn, why the hate for Violet?
  randomgayname 4y
  Yeah the name is kinda ehh imo, but w/e
  
  Ion like Violet. Its ass. Not rly a 0, but yeah
  Removed 4y
  fair enough.
  azstar0619 4y
  lol someone with a name "randomgayname" cannot really criticize someone else's name imo
  randomgayname 4y
  I was not even criticizing it, but aight
Cricri4055 4y
@randomgayname you watched 100x anime more than me, but devilman crybaby 4? I can understand a 5 but not 4
bjornAlgar 4y
what I felt more surprised about was you didn't enjoy vinland saga much, 7.5! nah it diserves more than that, and vinland saga is definetly not less than mha, nope! and yea no offence:)
Nicxcchi 4y
@doom4broom i think dr stone deserves more than a 7
- bjornAlgar 4y
  @elegxncy hmm
  i mean DR. was a good show for sure, but i didnt feel much about the second season of dr.stone as much as i felt it in the first season, either way dr.stone was an amazing anime can't wait for the 3rd season
TheStupidWolf 4y
@elegxncy all your 10 except Vinland saga surprised me, especially demon slayer.
- Nicxcchi 4y
  tbh most of my 10s where when i was fairly new to anime and when i enjoyed stuff i just rate them as 10.
  
  for food wars tbh i cant really remember much but i remember loving it so i rated them as 10, i'd love to rewatch one day though
victoriAX 4y
@TheStupidWolf
only a 4 for Violet?
- TheStupidWolf 4y
  https://anilist.co/forum/thread/39386/comment/1187462
  
  Dropped it at ep.7 some say that it gets better after ep.8 but i couldn't endure it anymore, for what i have watched it's a 4.
Maplx 4y
@vickymil TPN S2 a 7.2...?!?!?!?!?
- victoriAX 4y
  I haven’t read the manga so I didn’t find it THAT bad, but for me 7.2 means that I didn’t like it that much anyway
  zMelio 4y
  i didnt think it was that bad either, people over-hate it alot its more of a trend at this point
  victoriAX 4y
  yeah I mean, it could have been much better, but as an anime only it was not horrible, just okay
emptyroom 4y
@maplx 7 for akame ga kill….. ?
- Maplx 4y
  It's not everyday that I get to watch a show where all the characters die lol
  emptyroom 4y
  ah, fair enough ahaha!
zetsu7 4y
@emptyroom gabriel dropout a 10? im interested to hear your thoughts on the show
- emptyroom 4y
  ahaha, i might have a bit of a bias towards gabriel dropout, it’s such a good show to watch when i’m feeling shitty! i love all of the characters, the animation is bright n colourful, and for me the jokes always hit. plus it doesn’t feel like the usual slice-of-life show, feel like it has a bit more to it that i can’t quite put my finger on. i literally never get sick of it lol, plus bonus points for satania being an absolute joy
datte 4y
@Insidious your name.
datte 4y
Lots of plot holes.
datte 4y
There is no explanation for how and why they replaced their bodies. And the whole thing of time travel really ruined the movie.
- Leohere 4y
  id say thats more of a plot convivence than a plot hole
Lyadh 4y
@datte School Days a 10
- datte 4y
  forever a masterpiece.
TERR0R 4y
@Lyadh devilman at 6
- ameesaka 4y
  @coldrex
  
  5 star for black lagoon and 1 star for kokoro connect..
  TERR0R 4y
  i merged my 9's and 10's when i switched to the 5-star rating, black lagoon was a 9, it's everything i could ask for in a campy action show, entertaining as hell.
  kokoro connect started out alright, but it devolved into soap opera where every conflict is solved by the characters simply saying how they feel which is not how people communicate and by the end it drove me absolutely insane
- Lyadh 4y
  Didnt like the ending and the style is a bit too weird for me
Borbox 4y
@AmeeSouji Oregairu 2 is a bit too high imo
- ameesaka 4y
  It has my favorite moment of the whole series, so..
- YeetFeetDelete 4y
  we don't stan oregairu hate in this forum sir, take it somewhere else
foreverdumb 4y
@Borebon Biggest score for shit like Kimi no Na wa (I'm truly curious)
deelayed 4y
@Zuclyn
pupa??? 50 points? why i may ask?
Removed 4y
@patchouley

Your account is private so I can't really check your anime list.
- deelayed 4y
  its not though lol
  oops nevermind idk how that happened
Beeware 4y
@MilkAddict
Jujutsu Kaisen and Fate: UBW a 50 is making me sad but I get it.
Cricri4055 4y
@Beeware your name 8 it's a bit too much, that movie was boring for 55 minutes straight
Naueru 4y
@Cricri4055. Your mame 4.8 it's a bit too low for the Best movie ever
Leohere 4y
@Cricri4055 mha, the first and second season were better than the third and fourth imo

@Naueru tokyo revengers, the characters and plot makes no sense, i woudnt give it a 8.8
love 4y
@leohere
Clannad After Story
a 7.8 is unexpected. this being the same score as golden time is v surprising.
- Leohere 4y
  when i put scores in anime i dont really consider the other anime ive rated the same so even if they have the same scores doesnt mean i think they are equal
  also the AS ending was pretty unsatisfactory which resulted in minus points
  YeetFeetDelete 4y
  factssss
cora 4y
@gorilla toradora being rated higher than death note
- love 4y
  honestly surprises me too lmao imma change it
- whatdahaell 4y
  I LOVE THAT FEITAN FANART
TadomiK 4y
i agree with almost all of ur score

maybe Darling in the Franxx and Riddle Story of Devil are pretty low, i mean, DiF was quite interesting except the ending, not ur best meccha outthere but hey, its something.
And for Riddle, idk, maybe i enjoyed it too much?? didnt understand the ending, quite disaster, but pretty enjoyable ^^
@gorilla

and if someone replies to urs while im writing this, i dont give a fo.
IshigamiSenkuu 4y
@eternal
It has to be Naruto 1/10
Naruto

I personally love it but I understand that not everyone is going to, but I can't even imagine how this would be a 1 and at the same time your lowest rated anime. Same goes for shippuden which you gave a 2/10.
Duvet 4y
@IshigamiSenkuu
Naruto
SmashBlack 4y
@IshigamiSenkuu Sword Art Online

@Duvet K-ON!
- Brissinger 4y
  Psycho Pass 5.9? On my planlist currently but i heard mostly good things about season 1.
omashune 4y
All anime from ur anime list deserve their own ratings, except BNHA. I don't understand how u watch this childish shit :)
- YeetFeetDelete 4y
  some people just like the simple things in life. In regards to your anime ratings, they look good to me. Most I can say is I guess Your Name. at a 5, pretty low, but not really deal-breaking. Good stuff [imagine a thumbs up emoji right here]
Krankastel 4y
Yeah, it is those, plus Kizu II. Anyway:

Kizu I: too empty, streched and slow-burn.

Kizu II: lukewarm impressions, some intense gore and fine cinematic visuals.

Zoku: unecessary and streched. It was feeling like a spoonfeeding on characters' supposedly non-apparent sides and a trick to earn some money.
- hachihiraga 4y
  seems fair, i can't say i'd give them that score myself but i can see why you, probably a better critic, would
  Krankastel 4y
  Oh well, in the end of the day it boils down to enjoyment. If I enjoyed them more, perhaps suspension of disbelief would make me say different things.

more replies on anilist →