Help me, choosing my next Anime

Since you have many Battle Shounen ones;
Magi The Labyrinth of Magic
It's more of fantasy tho. But yeah, give it a try.

Out of all of these I've only watched/am in the process of watching Monogatari

so watch that if your okay with lolis
like im talking actual groping sexual assault type shit

Gintama

Considering what you've seen before, I absolutely recommend Magi. I'm sure you'll love it.

Hmm all these seem like good choices so I'm going to help you with some of them (the ones I know).

If you have the time to watch 50 or so mid episodes but have one of the best comedies then watch Gintama.

If you want an anime with a lot of dialogue, great characters and an artistic direction unlike any other start the Monogatari Series.

Next one is Eva, nuff said.

I could be biased and say Monogatari but do what you want.

Monogatari Series

I'd say Magi, I myself am only 2 episodes in but I'm absolutely loving it already

Magi easily

Gintama.

monogatari series

Go with Magi

Gintama and Monogatari series are great but quite long. If you are prepared to watch em, go for it

Magi is more rewarding with its tight arcs and less episodes overall. So that would be my pick.

dunno about the other two

I think you should definitely watch NGE first, its a really good series. But if you're looking for a longer watch you should go for Gintama

gintama

gintama.

i say evangelion

gintama for sure. you like one piece so you wouldnt mind watching a series with a bit of a slow start .
but it pays off, trust me