Site Feedback

Why is this on the top 100 list

confusedpotat · 2y

3221

this is like if letterboxd let documentaries into the top 250

gnir 2y
AniList is not letterboxd.

(Also big L from letterboxd for not including documentaries.)
Rinko 2y
Yeah, music videos should not be allowed on the top 100, that just feels weird...

Maybe no one ever expected a music video would actually get that sort of score?
Removed 2y
better than Berserk
gilo 2y
the west has fallen
Hachi13 2y
I also think that it would be better to separate music videos from the other formats.
Hyliaforce 2y
Thats how peak the song is
- Iryi 2y
  when your 3:46 music video beats most anime on its own.
menherachan 2y
replying for update
Keedregeth 2y
Feels wrong for this to be allowed a spot in the websites top 100 anime listings
- Shirox 2y
  I'd argue that it'd be wrong to purposefully exclude it.
  Top100 is the 100 entries with the highest mean (? average? not sure) score, and if its got a high enough score to be part of that, then so be it
  Rinko 2y
  
  highest mean (? average? not sure) score
  
  Average. Everything prioritises the weighted average.
  I mean if it didn't that light novel with 100% mean score I stumbled on a couple months back would be way more popular...~
Taluun 2y
I don't know why people think MVs and the like shouldn't be included
- Rinko 2y
  To be honest, I don't get why people bother to track music videos in the first place.
  And in general it just... it's not really a proper anime? Yeah it's animated, yeah it's from Japan, but like... it's a music video, not an anime or movie or anything like that... it just does not feel like it belongs there.
  
  MVs and the like
  
  ...Huh? I feel like it's only music videos that get this sort of reaction (though there is of course only the one) and like... the people complaining about tons of entries from the same series at the top have a pretty different sort of complaint.
  Taluun 2y
  
  not an anime or movie or anything like that.
  
  MVs and the like
  
  Chibi specials, commercials/PVs, experimental shorts, etc. All the things that aren't "anime or movie or anything like that"
  Rinko 2y
  
  Chibi specials, commercials/PVs, experimental shorts, etc.
  
  Ah, those things... I haven't really heard complaints about those myself, but I guess that makes sense. Though, with the exception of adverts, those feel a lot more anime-like than MVs... what with comedy and/or plot being a much stronger aspect, I think. That definitely goes for the chibi shorts/specials, though I can see a slightly less-crisp line with other things...
- Maruisalone 2y
  taluun as always based af
pori6014 2y
yeah its especially dumb when the song is 30 places above the actual show its from. music should have its own category/not be included at all. comparing 4 minute music videos to mult-hour shows is like comparing apples to oranges
- liraila 1y
  big W
jackie 1y
We agree!
SailorDoom 1y
Why not? There's an option to filter by format if you wanna exclude MVs from the list
AmanK 1y
I completely agree it overshadows the other deserving anime that could be on there