4/5
Eva, Marnie, Sword, Legends.
I didn't much like the plot of Millennium Actress even though I'd consider it to be the most well made anime of those I've seen here.
I've only seen Brotherhood (great), not the original.

3/5, I love Sennen Joyuu, Gintama and Omoide no Marnie. I've also seen FMA:B and NGE.

3/6

2/4: I prefer the Brotherhood series to the 2003 one, and I didn't like Evangelion, but I loved Millennium Actress and Omoide no Marnie. Galactic Heroes, Sword of the Stranger and Arete Hime are in my Planning list (:

3/6