M - Makeine Too Many Losing Heroines
A - Aoashi
H - HIGH CARD
R - Ragna Crimson
D - Dragon Quest The Adventure of Dai
Y - Yofukashi no Uta
B - Boku no Kokoro no Yabai Yatsu
M - MASHLE
Interesting idea but I do have some doubts regarding this forum game.
for each letter of the user
There might be cases where people might have multiple occurrences of the same letter like in your case. Since there was only one, I've repeated it but do add clarification regarding this specific case in the rules of the forum game.
I use English Titles so there might be discrepancies since the Romanji titles don't always match with the English ones. I only decided to use the Romoaji Titles after seeing your example. So, should that be left to the user?