I'm just wondering what's wrong with mother's basement.
The problem with him is he fails to analyze anime.
Here’s what I mean by that.
That’s why mothers basement fucking sucks
Those are a very small portion of the videos on his channel, and they are all from quite a while ago. You cant say a youtuber sucks just because you don't like a few of their videos
Well I stopped watching his channel a while ago but I don’t care about him anymore because I just find his content boring and also I don’t like videos when they talk about how great a show is because of one element. To make a point on why a show is great you have to talk about characters, execution and other stuff besides 1 element
What's wrong with him talking about his favourite element of an anime? Him not talking about every single aspect of every anime he wants to talk about doesn't make him a bad youtube, like you were implying he was
Well here the thing though most competent reviewers actually make a critique on everything about it so people understand why the show is good or bad and make points where people can counterargue. For example DXFan619 often makes reviews of anime and actually dissects the plot and writing of anime in a logical and coherent way that often feels satisfying when you watch his videos because there are actually real points when when discussing the plot in a series whether it would be bad or good. You would most likely know him well for his series on YouTube called Anime I F-Word Hate which is where he tears apart Anime he believes are actually stupid and really just pretend to have deeper meaning when they really don’t. I’m not saying his word is gospel or anything. There are a few reviews I kind of disagree with. My point is that he at least tries his best to find the deeper meaning within an anime and sometimes works hard to create videos that are nearly an hour long for his viewers.