According to you,which is the most over-rated anime and the most under-rated anime?

Part 2 does have some of those scenes where Joseph reveals that he was doing something while the enemy was distracted, but personally it's still my second favourite part after part 7. Mainly because of how focused the fights were (only a few enemies, whereas other parts have dozens) and how much better the pacing was compared to other parts. However it's fair to not be into that kind of stuff in fights, so your criticism does make sense. There is definitely less of that as the series goes on I would say, especially part 4 onwards.

Your first BGS criticism is a little odd though. Naturally there are set interactions that happen between the characters, but Monogatari has the same thing. Araragi and Hachikuji's whole "you said my name wrong" thing happens many times throughout the series and doesn't change at all. It's a completely repetitive exchange that doesn't change, whereas Sakuta's jokes usually do change (simply with what words he chooses and what situations he uses them in) and are always funny.

In terms of storylines being uninteresting, I suppose that one's completely subjective. I thought they were all interesting and unique but there were clearly ones that were stronger than others (Mai's and Kaede's in particular were fantastic).

The scientific explanations are there to explain how things are going on, which is only a good thing. Also, I'd say you're right about them being there to get you more invested into Futaba. That's also absolutely a good thing, as it allowed for many interactions and fun back-and-forths between her and Sakuta.

As for there being basically no banter, I'd disagree. His interactions with Mai, Futaba, and Koga were always really fun to watch. Obviously there isn't as much banter in sheer quantity as Monogatari because that series is incredibly long, but regardless I found all the interactions to be fun and natural-feeling.

And I do agree that emotional scenes aren't absolutely necessary for a show to be good, but my main problem with Monogatari is that so little actually seems to happen. When I look back on the events of Monogatari I don't think "wow, that arc was so memorable" or "that exchange made me feel 'x' way". The exception is the Nadeko arc from S2 which was genuinely great.
I love seeing characters interact and engage in regular conversations, but for Monogatari that seemed to comprise 95% of the show. In my opinion, Bunny Girl Senpai balanced this much better with plenty of interactions/conversations between the characters, along with more important or engaging events in the story.

I would also say that the emotional scenes do help a lot for shows like Monogatari or Bunny Girl Senpai, as those shows are focused all around the struggles of characters. I feel like the problems that the characters are having get through to me better if there are impactful emotional scenes incorporated into their stories.

For example, a scene where Senjoughara breaks down after her aberration problem was solved in the first arc. It was such a struggle for her, you'd think her relief to be free of it would evoke a stronger reaction. You might think of this as forced, since Senjoughara doesn't show her emotions often, but what of the scene where Senjoughara breaks down after seeing Hanekawa sleep in the cram school? It really doesn't make sense to have her cry so much in that situation, as she barely even knows Hanekawa. She breaks down seeing that yet doesn't when she's finally free of the crab aberration?

In the same vein, I also found Araragi's reaction when he finds out that Hanekawa didn't have a room for herself in her house to be so incredibly forced. He literally starts shaking, crying and yelling, jumps out of the room on the second story of the house, rushes home and buries himself in Tsukihi's lap while she's wearing no pants (another one of Monogatari's many forced fanservice scenes).
Like yeah, Hanekawa obviously has a family situation going on but his reaction was so thoroughly unrealistic and over the top that I couldn't take it seriously. I would have liked to see THAT kind of reaction in a more emotional scene. With his ridiculous reaction I was expecting to see torture devices set up by her family in that room with blood all over, not the fact that she doesn't have a room to herself.

Last but not least there was also Senjoughara in Nisemonogatari, who completely contradicts the values of her character. She basically becomes Hanekawa's boot-licker because she's scared of her threat that she'll take Araragi away from her. Since when did Senjoughara become so weak? Her ENTIRE character is built around being strong/resilient because of what happened to her in her past, yet that's all thrown away here.

You could argue that she's being weak because it has to do with Araragi who she loves, but that's really not good enough. Senjoughara would be verbally destroying Hanekawa and telling her that if she threatens to take Araragi away from her again she'll kill her, not talking to her like she's become her servant.

You might also argue that she's doing this because she believes there's a chance that Araragi could actually be taken away/swayed by Hanekawa. But that isn't good enough either, because Senjoughara had never met or seen Hanekawa before their phone call, so she'd have no idea what kind of relationship she has with Araragi.

This ended up being a little longer than I was planning haha.

Oh wow, we must not be browsing the same places then I guess

b r u h

I feel Sao wouldn't have gotten all the hate if the series had ended after 13 episodes with Asuna escaped.The rest of the seasons are just pushed to throw any garbage at the audience.I hope SAO ends soon.

as expected of a man of your stature