There are some issues with how I handle unrated shows and I'm open to any recommendations!
Not sure about handling that would work for all cases, but as a point of reference I can explain my case. For now I am just marking titles that I really liked with positive smiley rating and I don't really mark anything else. Sometimes that might mean "not sure about that one", sometimes I just forget to rate. Because of that I think it's better to consider unrated titles as a separate thing and not try to guess whether it's negative, neutral or positive
To solve the issues on my page specifically:
I might be an outlier, but because I didn't rate my views that much and all three ratings this year were positive smileys, some of the cards are a bit funny, but in the different way than before:
Feel free to check my Wrapped link for testing if needed - https://unofficial-anilist-wrapped.vercel.app/wrapped/jellymath