Darker than BLACK Kuro no Keiyakusha

This was the first anime I watched online, I'm actually glad I started with something good over something bad. Hunter x Hunter 2011
The first anime I watched that wasn't online was this one.Soul Eater

Isekai Fantasy
ReZero kara Hajimeru Isekai Seikatsu

Medieval time fantasy
Akatsuki no Yona

Romance fantasy
Akagami no Shirayukihime

This anime will give you a fun time.
Ishuzoku Reviewers

Cross country or just running was never a thing that I thought of trying, but this anime and its portrayal of students learning and striving to run when they rarely or never did was really inspirational.
Kaze ga Tsuyoku Fuiteiru

For no reason

Glad to hear! Enjoy the watch!

Mafia and gang fights, plently of action.
BANANA FISH

More drama centered
Hoshiai no Sora

Focuses on how to express emotions through music, I had a blast watching this one and it hits well when it is supposed too.
Given

This one is good, but I don't know if it has yuri.
NANA

Halloween

Kino no Tabi: The Beautiful World

My username comes from how I can easily get salty when I'm to into a game, and the paws part simply comes from how I'm studying to be a veterinarian.

@KenOh30 6/10, KenOh rolls off pretty nice, but i'm not a fan of numbers in usernames, aside from that it seems pretty simple

@littlefemmefatale
Fuck: Faye Valentine
Marry: Akane Tsunemori
Kill: Ban

@rxdiantfaith besides absolutely loving haikyuu, you like a mix of the energetic and hyper characters that jump around everywhere, and the cool, calm, and collected characters that think things through.

@SasoriNeko
12 - Inosuke Hashibira
The wild boar, that got tamed

Hahahaahahah, yeah it has nudity, that's why i was surprised when you said you got it at 11. Hope you enjoy the read, I sure did.

At 11? That's wild, if you have the first volume in physical I'd definitely say give it another try. Unless it doesn't pander into your taste in manga.

These three I'm going to give are each different, I'm not sure if one can consider them underrated, but I haven't seen many people talking about any of these.
Tongari Boushi no Atelier
This one is magic centered, but it has a good spin to it that changes things from the common magic formula other shows and literature works take. Careful with spoilers.

Bokura wa Minna Kawaisou
The Kawai Complex Guide is a very fun read, for me personally it's the best romance work I have read, or seen up to now. It involves the life of the mc living in a boarding house along multiple intricate personalities, and his high school crush is also living there. It's also really funny and the jokes and gags it has don't get stale over time.

bel Blatt
Ubel Blatt is very similar to Berserk (from what I have been told), it takes the betrayal aspect and gives it a supernatural touch, focusing on the characters thirst for revenge no matter the cost. it's in a fantasy setting so it has otherworldly creatures, magic and other races besides humans.

I'm not sure what it is that you are looking for, or even if you are looking for something, but I tried to make each entry as varied as possible for you. I hope you enjoy one of these if not all :).

For a more drama romance anime I'd recommend:
Yagate Kimi ni Naru Cross Game
Cross game involves sports, but it's more focused on the drama and romance aspects.

If you are looking for something with more comedy (these still have drama, but not as heavily), I would recommend:
Bokura wa Minna Kawaisou
Kaichou wa Maidsama

I second this man, this anime is quite complicated, but if you stick through with it it's a very fun experience and a good watch, having lots of vibrant colour for its world and a good animation to boot.
Kyousougiga TV

Manga City Beach Challenge

Challenge Start Date: 09/04/2019
Challenge Finish Date: DD/MM/YYYY

1. [O] Start: DD/MM/YYYY Finish: DD/MM/YYYY Read a manga that takes place on a relatively small island Umineko no Naku Koro ni Episode 1: Legend of the Golden Witch
2. [O] Start: DD/MM/YYYY Finish: DD/MM/YYYY Read a Manga with a scene/panel where a character wears a swimsuit Boku-tachi wa Benkyou ga Dekinai Last chapter read: Screenshot:
3. [O] Start: DD/MM/YYYY Finish: DD/MM/YYYY Sun “exposure”: Read a manga with the genre “Ecchi” or with the tag “Nudity” Sabishisugite Lesbian Fuzoku Ni Ikimashita Report
4. Start: 30/09/2018 Finish: DD/MM/YYYY Read a manga that features swimming, diving or surfing equipment Grand Blue
5. [O] Start: DD/MM/YYYY Finish: DD/MM/YYYY Beach activities: Read a manga with the tag “Volleyball” or “Swimming” or “Fishing” Haikyuu!!
6. [O] Start: DD/MM/YYYY Finish: DD/MM/YYYY Read a manga that is the source of an anime from the AWC Beaches list Nisekoi
7. [O] Start: DD/MM/YYYY Finish: DD/MM/YYYY Hot Topic: Read a manga from the first 15 on the Trending page Hinamatsuri Screenshot:
8. Start: 20/12/2018 Finish: DD/MM/YYYY Shipwrecked: Read a manga with the tag “Survival” or “Ships” Shoujo Shuumatsu Ryokou
9. Start: 06/03/2019 Finish: DD/MM/YYYY Ocean waves: Read a manga that has at least 3 major rises and falls in its activity stats 5-Toubun no Hanayome (Previously at chapter: 100) Last chapter read: Screenshot:
10. [O] Start: DD/MM/YYYY Finish: DD/MM/YYYY Shark Attack! Read a manga that another person has thrown out (recommended) as a rescue wheel Yagate Kimi ni Naru Link: https://anilist.co/forum/thread/8889/comment/193439

Save another participant (optional): Recommend your own manga Houseki no Kuni